Three years have passed since audiences first sailed alongside Moana and Maui in their charming quest across the ocean. In “Moana 2,” we encounter a more seasoned Moana, who steps into her role as a wayfinder. Set against the backdrop of her ancestors’ call, Moana embarks on a mission to find the fabled island of Motufetu. This journey entails uniting her crew to confront the age-old curse imposed by the deity Nalo, which has long kept the oceanic inhabitants fragmented. There is an identifiable attempt at growth and maturity in Moana’s character. However, the film ultimately falls short in meaningful character development, particularly in contrast to the original, which celebrated the importance of personal journeys and evolution.
While “Moana 2” features the returning voices of Auli’i Cravalho and Dwayne Johnson, the film also introduces a broader cast of shipmates, yet their presence does little to drive the narrative forward. The lack of engaging arcs for even the prominent characters feels like a missed opportunity to further explore their relationships and personal journeys. What could have been a riveting narrative filled with depth and dynamic interactions is instead diluted into a string of predictable encounters. This can regrettably lead viewers, especially adult audiences who may seek more substantial content, to question the motivations behind the sequel’s creation.
Initially intended as a limited series for Disney+, “Moana 2” has been adapted for the big screen while retaining traces of its original episodic format. The result is a film that mirrors the familiar, nostalgic style reminiscent of Disney’s ’90s animated features. Although the film attempts to tick all the boxes of a standard Disney sequel—with its zany sidekicks, adorable characters, and catchy tunes—it struggles to recapture the enthralling originality that defined its predecessor. The soundtrack may entertain children, yet lacks that memorable impact made by Lin-Manuel Miranda’s compositions from the first film.
Despite these shortcomings, “Moana 2” presents itself as a charming visual feast. The stunning animation and vibrant colors bring the oceans of Oceania to life, effectively capturing the attention of younger viewers. The film’s escapism provides a perfect winter distraction for families distancing themselves from the cold. Yet, while it may entertain children with its engaging visuals and child-centric humor, it struggles to resonate with older audiences. The simplistic narrative limits its potential for repeat viewership, as adults may find the experience lacking in depth.
“Moana 2” serves as an entertaining escape for families but falls short in delivering the transformative qualities that made its predecessor a modern classic. While there is enough charm to entice a new generation of young fans, it lacks the emotional depth and character exploration that could have broadened its appeal. As it heads towards its eventual release on Disney+, audiences will likely reflect on the film wishing for the richness and heart that defined the original Moana experience.